What caught my eye this week.

The ‘proper’ savings rate for a pursuer of financial freedom is one of those perennial hand grenades lobbed into the otherwise cozy and supportive world of personal finance blogging.

Partly that’s because of fundamental differences in philosophy when it comes to how many fingers to raise – and how vigorously – when faced with the endless temptations of consumer culture.

But mostly it’s because we all have different values and financial situations. We’re at different stages in our journeys, too.

Hence we see the spectacle of comfortably retired Boomers berating 20-somethings for ordering a bit of avocado on toast, while other 20-somethings shame their own for getting a latte from Starbucks (shameful, true, but not for financial reasons) – and everything in-between.

When I bought my flat, I also bought a fancy coffee machine. I’d wanted one for at least a decade and for me it was part of the home ownership dream.

But to some readers it was akin to Bob Dylan going electric at the Newport Folk Festival.

Never mind that I could easily afford it – and I’d waited until I could, too – or that my savings rate had been 20-50% for 20 years. That I’ve never bought a car, let alone several cars, in my life. Or that a good coffee is one of my top ten hedonistic pleasures.

They didn’t like it – and yet other readers slapped me on the back.

Enjoy yourself, they smiled. Ignore the haters!

Comparison shopping

Funnily enough I didn’t feel massively more kinship with the latter than the former.

That’s because we all had – and have – a lot more in common with each other than could be divided by a homemade espresso.

While others read the footie results or catch up on Love Island, here we find ourselves on a pretty niche money and investing blog. We’re all looking to put or keep our finances on a decent footing. And making our own decisions daily about what to splurge on and what to eschew.

The only contention is that one person’s luxury treat is another person’s wasteful squandering. That his cost-saving gambit is her unthinkable sacrifice.

A luxury you just can’t forfeit might not even register for me.

You drive a BMW Coupe 343 B-Liner Sedan Thingywotsit? Really?!

At least I think that’s what you said. Knock yourself out.

I don’t do cars. Maybe you don’t do espresso machines. It’s silly arguing over the specifics.

The big picture – money in, money out, investing the rest – is what matters.

Better latte than never

It’s a similar story with savings rates.

If you’ve no money socked away at 50 and you tell me you’re going to start saving 5% of your salary into a SIPP, then I’m going to tell you it’s not enough.

Until, that is, you tell me you’re earning £500,000 a year…

At the same time a 22-year old saving 5% of their fairly ordinary professional salary – topped up by the company and the government – may well be on their way to become a millionaire by the usual retirement age without ever feeling they sacrificed anything.

Which in turn leads to those circular arguments about whether compound interest matters or not.

If you only start saving properly when you’re a decade away from retiring, I agree it’s not going to do much for you.

If you began in your early 20s and now you’re in your 50s – seeing a good year in the stock market bolt more than your annual salary onto your portfolio – well, it’s hard to know where to begin.

It all adds up

Nick Maggiulli over at Of Dollars and Data therefore did everyone a great favour this week by pinning some numbers onto this age-old drama.

By showing how the impact of saving a bit extra varies depending on how much you’re already saving – and for how long you intend to keep at it – Nick has revealed the mathematics behind the emotions in these debates.

For example, let’s say you are currently on-track to retire in 20 years. Nick’s table below shows how many years of work you could avoid if you increase your savings rate by three different amounts:

So if you’re already saving 20% of your salary, for instance, then save 5% more for the rest of your working years and you could actually retire three years and a bit earlier.

What’s striking about this table is actually how little difference saving even more money makes once you’re already putting away a healthy 20% or more of your income. That’s given the long time horizon at work.

Have all the avocados and lattes you like, my young and disciplined friends!

In contrast, if you’re only currently saving 5% to be on-target to retire in 30 years, then tripling your saving rate could nearly halve your remaining years in the office.

There’s plenty more insights unearthed by Nick’s tables and graphs, so go read it.

And have a great weekend!

p.s. Thank you to everyone who has already signed up to become a Monevator member. It’s truly gratifying and the strong start has encouraged us to think we can eventually become a sustainable operation. What’s more, many of you shared some generous words, too. If you haven’t already read the more than 130 comments from readers on last Saturday’s post, please do! And thanks again.

From Monevator

What do rising rates mean for our portfolios? – Monevator [For members]

Mortgages and emotions: 2022’s interest rate mayhem – Monevator

From the archive-ator: The obvious thing we all forget when we borrow money – Monevator


Note: Some links are Google search results – in PC/desktop view click through to read the article. Try privacy/incognito mode to avoid cookies. Consider subscribing to sites you visit a lot.

Bank of England raises key interest rate by 0.25% to 4.5%… – Sky News

…and warns UK inflation will stay higher for longer it thought – BBC

Meanwhile UK economy expanded by just 0.1% in Q1 2023 – BBC

What do higher interest rates mean for your finances? – Which

Government drops plans to scrap leasehold property system – Guardian

Grocery chiefs warn new Brexit red tape could empty shelves – Independent

London: a “very problematic” stock market – CNBC

Global prime property index falls for the first time since 2009 [PDF]Knight Frank

Products and services

Cheap and free things to do over the holidays – Which

Skipton launches first 100% mortgage since 2008 – MoneySavingExpert

Blackrock and Vanguard ETFs will dominate for years – ETF.com

Open a SIPP with Interactive Investor and pay no SIPP fee for six months. Terms apply – Interactive Investor

Consumers on ditching gas central heating for heat pumps – Guardian

Backlash grows over new efficiency rules for landlords – This Is Money

Open an account with low-cost platform InvestEngine via our link and get £25 when you invest at least £100 (T&Cs apply. Capital at risk) – InvestEngine

What are your supermarket loyalty points worth? – Be Clever With Your Cash

‘Reverse ATMs’ at some US stores swap cash for pre-pay cards… – Axios

…while also in the US, a new fintech is targeting the over-60s – TechCrunch

Homes for sale in the super-suburbs, in pictures – Guardian

Comment and opinion

Should you save more to retire earlier? – Of Dollars and Data

Three lessons from the 60/40’s stumble – Morningstar

Defined benefit pensions: not dead yet [Search result]FT

Asking the wrong questions – Oblivious Investor

The future will be… something – Fortunes & Frictions

Tim Harford: not everyone can substitute away inflation [Search result]FT

Free to be – Humble Dollar

Revisiting the Permanent Portfolio – DIY Investor UK

The use case for FOMO investing – Think Advisor

Debating nationalizing the UK water companies [Podcast]ALTIF

“We won’t be able to pay this much”: higher rates hit home – Guardian

Be an emotional person, just not with your money – Darius Foroux

The harvest that matters – Simple Living in Somerset

Pay’s the issue, but don’t forget public sector pensions – David Smith

US recession obsession mini-special

What’s the best asset type to hold during a recession? – Morningstar

Gold versus inflation, stagflation, and recession – Institutional Investor

Swap and credit spreads still say no US recession – Califia Beach Pundit

US interest rate hiking cycles compared [Infographic]Visual Capitalist

Naughty corner: Active antics

Be glad short sellers exist and [sort of] conspire – Capital Gains

Should investors trust their gut? – Behavioral Investment

Mayday for Interactive Broker margin lending – Fire V London

Boost your returns with a very, very long vacation – Morningstar

Diversification or di-worse-ification? – Verdad

The physical world can affect an investor’s returns – Institutional Investor

Kindle book bargains

The Moneyless Man: A Year of Freeconomic Living by Mark Boyle – £0.99 on Kindle

200 Years of Muddling Through: The British Economy by Duncan Weldon – £0.99 on Kindle

A Journey Through Labour’s Lost England by Sebastian Payne – £0.99 on Kindle

Too Big To Jail: The Greatest Banking Scandal of the Century by Chris Blackhurst – £0.99 on Kindle

Environmental factors

The people living ultra-low-carbon lifestyles – BBC Future Planet

A patch of seaweed is growing to record size in the Atlantic – Vox

Seaflooding – Uncharted Territories

How wild pigs retook Singapore – Hakai

Why climate change is not an environmental issue – The Walrus

Robot overlord roundup

Schooled – Indeedably

How AI knows things nobody told it – Scientific American

Google reveals AI updates as it vies with Microsoft – BBC

Artificial Intelligence is not going to kill us all – Slate

ChatGPT fever is attracting billions in VC funding – Wall Street Journal [h/t AR]

Will a robot take YOUR job? [Data, US]Will Robots Take My Job

Off our beat

The star athlete family office – Profluence Sports

Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is the best Switch game ever made – Inverse

Should we abandon the ‘war’ on cancer? – Aeon

Read The Economist backwards [Podcast, or scroll for text]Russell Clark

Who better to sing old Brexit tunes than this over-hyped new act? – Marina Hyde

Monkeys and the ‘reverse salient’ – Annie Duke

A 102-year old doctor on letting go to be happier – CNBC

How Russia’s invasion transformed one Ukranian city [With graphics]Vox

R.I.P. Metaverse – Business Insider

And finally…

“People will choose unhappiness over uncertainty.”
– Tim Ferris, The 4-Hour Work Week

Like these links? Subscribe to get them every Friday. Note this article includes affiliate links, such as from Amazon and Interactive Investor.

The post Weekend reading: It’s savings rates all the way down appeared first on Monevator.

Receive the latest news in your email
Table of content
Related articles